Entrepreneurship Ecosystem Insights
  • Home
  • Content
    • Perspectives
    • Innovative Programs & Policies
    • Research You Should Know
    • In Case You Missed It
  • About Endeavor
    • Our Mission
    • Our Model
    • Our Entrepreneurs
    • Insight & Research
    • Investor Network
    • Programs
    • Our Background
    • FAQS
  • About EEI
Research You Should Know 1

How Local and State Governments Can Best Support Entrepreneurship

By Endeavor Insight · On April 15, 2015

Public support of entrepreneurship seems to be all the rage in policy circles, and yet in 2011 only about 8 percent of American businesses were new, compared to 15 percent 1970. Inspired by this frustrating truth, the Kauffman Foundation has produced a report called ‘Guidelines for Local and State Governments to Promote Entrepreneurship‘ based on lessons learned from the foundation’s entrepreneurship support programs. Here are a few of their most interesting findings:

State and Local Governments Should Stop Supporting Two Bad Ideas – Public Venture Funds and Incubation Centers

Public venture funds have a poor track record. Operating any venture fund is risky and challenging, let alone one funded by taxpayer dollars. Most venture funds fail and the ones that do not tend to generate smaller rates of return than the standard rate for the public stock market. This, coupled with the lacking expertise of public sector employees in the realm of venture capitalism, makes public venture funds an especially questionable use of public funds.

Public incubation centers also are weak performers. Public business incubators, an increasingly popular concept, are established to meet entrepreneurs’ need for capital. They rarely succeed at doing so: unless a startup requires expensive equipment, an physical incubator does not help them, but it may keep alive businesses that would not otherwise survive.

Local Governments Should Increase Support for High-Performing Programs – Network Building and Support Targeted by Stage

Fostering connections and learning among entrepreneurs leverages local strengths. The Kauffman Foundation’s main recommendation is to concentrate on the people behind businesses, who learn by doing an interacting with each other. Entrepreneurs like to learn from others in the same business environment, but they often find it hard to make the connections. This is where a local government can help: through events and other platforms, they can bring entrepreneurs together.

Organizing business communities around different stages of entrepreneurship offers more relevant support. Public programs should direct businesses to the forums that would meet their needs best. While meeting others in the same developmental stage (nascent ventures, startups, or scaleups) can facilitate technical learning and innovation, meeting with businessmen further ahead may help entrepreneurs find mentors, investors, or inspiration.

In General, Bottom-Up Approaches Work Better Than Top-Down Strategies

It is no coincidence that both of the bad ideas described above are top-down strategies, conceived in the minds of policymakers and imposed on the industries that should theoretically benefit from these newly created institutions. It is also interesting to note that the recommended ideas are also both bottom-up approaches. As it has also been demonstrated in other studies, the power of entrepreneurship lies within the connections among businesses: inspiration, mentoring, angel investment, serial entrepreneurship, and employee spin-offs. To harness these connections, successful support strategies should concentrate on bringing businesses together.

Contributed by Lili Torok.

Print Friendly
acceleratorsentrepreneurial ecosystementrepreneurship ecosystemsincubatorskauffman foundationpublic policysupportventure capital
Share Tweet

You Might Also Like

  • Research You Should Know

    Place-Based Innovation Policies are Important for Building Entrepreneurial Ecosystems

  • Research You Should Know

    Middle American Cities Are Some of the Nation’s Largest Talent Generators

  • Research You Should Know

    National Governments Want More Companies to Scale

1 Comment

  • Steven Koltai says: April 18, 2015 at 8:06 am

    Great article going behind the headlines – incubators and funds ALONE don’t turn the tide, its about creating a balanced ecosystem that includes mentors and support networks AS WELL

    Reply
  • Leave a reply Cancel reply

    Subscribe to our monthly update

    • Popular
    • Comments
    • Tags
    • How Can Decision Makers Foster Productive Entrepreneurship Communities?

      October 29, 2018
    • Three Tips for Entrepreneurship Policy-Makers from Philip Auerswald

      October 14, 2015
    • The Three Most Important Resources Companies Need to Succeed

      March 10, 2014
    • Start-Up Chile: Heading toward Failure or Success?

      September 9, 2014
    • How Five Percent of Kenyan Companies Can Help Create 3.9 Million Jobs

      May 11, 2015
    • How Local and State Governments Can Best Support Entrepreneurship

      April 15, 2015
    • ride says: Тhanks for finally writing about >The Three Most Important Resourϲes Compan...
    • American Dreamers says: Very insightful article. This can help out all aspiring ...
    • Steven Koltai says: In my work in 36 countries over the past 8 years beginning as the first Senior...
    • Mark Neild says: Of course it may be that just providing entrepreneurs in developing countries ...
    • Endeavor Insight says: Thank you, Julia! Big hugs from Team Insight....
    entrepreneurial ecosystem entrepreneurship ecosystems access to finance entrepreneurship startups access to capital jobs scaleups entrepreneurship policy research success high-growth firms economic growth smes public policy economic development europe high-growth

    Perspectives

    • Network Building Sets Women Entrepreneurs Up for Success

      February 12, 2020
    • Emerging Fintech Entrepreneurship in the African Remittance Market

      June 29, 2017
    • Xavier Niel is Building the World’s Largest Startup Incubator in Paris

      May 26, 2016

    Innovative Programs & Policies

    • How Social Entrepreneurs ‘Zig-Zag’ Their Way to Scale

      December 5, 2019
    • Five Ways for Entrepreneurship Support Programs to Become More Effective

      November 22, 2019
    • What Types of Companies Have the Strongest Impact on Economic Growth?

      June 7, 2019

    Research You Should Know

    • Place-Based Innovation Policies are Important for Building Entrepreneurial Ecosystems

      March 30, 2020
    • Middle American Cities Are Some of the Nation’s Largest Talent Generators

      March 23, 2020
    • National Governments Want More Companies to Scale

      March 12, 2020

    In Case You Missed It

    • What Is the Typical Career Path of CEOs at Large Firms?

      July 24, 2019
    • The Fintech Sector is Rapidly Expanding in Latin America

      June 25, 2018
    • Scaling Entrepreneurs Drive Innovation in Emerging Markets

      June 7, 2018

    Endeavor

    To learn more about Endeavor and our worldwide network of high-growth companies please visit our website.

    © Endeavor 2019. All rights reserved.